Alligator Po' Boy
Recipe #370

Alligator Po' Boy

Alligator Recipe

Serves:4
Prep:25 minutes
Cook:15 minutes
Difficulty:Easy

1Setup & Prepare

Cultural Context

This iconic New Orleans sandwich showcases fried alligator in the traditional po' boy format, creating a dish that's both authentically Louisiana and uniquely American. The po' boy represents the working-class roots of New Orleans cuisine, where excellent ingredients were made accessible through familiar presentations.

2Ingredients

Shopping List

13 ingredients total8 with images2 with substitutions

3Cooking Instructions

  1. Marinating: Soak alligator strips in buttermilk for 30 minutes to tenderize.

  2. Breading Setup: Combine flour, cornmeal, Cajun seasoning, and salt in large bowl.

  3. Oil Heating: Heat oil to 375°F in deep fryer or large pot.

  4. Bread Preparation: Split French bread loaves and hollow out slightly to make room for filling.

  5. Breading: Remove alligator from buttermilk and dredge in seasoned flour mixture.

  6. Frying: Fry breaded alligator in batches 3-4 minutes until golden brown and cooked through (145°F internal temperature).

  7. Assembly: Spread mayonnaise on bread. Layer with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and hot fried alligator.

  8. Service: Serve immediately while alligator is hot and crispy. Provide hot sauce on the side.

4Chef's Notes & Pairings

Chef's Notes

  • Don't overcook the alligator or it becomes tough
  • Use authentic New Orleans French bread if available
  • Traditional "dressed" po' boys include lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and mayo

Wine Pairing

A cold beer or crisp white wine like Muscadet complements the fried seafood-style preparation.

Nutrition Facts

Per serving: 485 calories, 38g protein, 22g fat, 38g carbohydrates. Classic New Orleans comfort food.

5Interactive Recipe Tools

Rate this recipe:

Cooking Timers

My Recipe Notes